Doctor:
Beating Cut Off Teen's
Oxygen
An inability to
breathe during a boot
camp beating is what
killed the teenager,
says a pathologist.
By ALEX LEARY, Times Staff
Writer
Published March 18, 2006
TALLAHASSEE - The noted
pathologist who reviewed the
autopsy of Martin Lee
Anderson told lawmakers
Friday he thinks the
teenager died because he
could not breathe as he was
punched and kicked by guards
at a Panhandle boot camp.
Last week, Dr. Michael
Baden said Anderson did not
die of natural causes,
contradicting the initial
autopsy that ruled his death
the result of a genetic
disorder. Then Friday, he
further clarified his
position in a telephone
conference call to a
legislative committee
studying boot camps.
"He didn't have any
rupture of internal organs,"
Baden said, meaning the
kicks and punches themselves
did not cause death.
"He did have a number of
situations in which his
breathing was impaired,
episodes where there was
somebody pressing on his
back while he was on the
ground. That prevents the
diaphragm from moving and
can cause asphyxia, the lack
of breathing."
Baden, who spoke from New
York, also said there were
instances where guards
covered the 14-year-old's
mouth in order to force an
ammonia capsule up his
nostril, a tactic guards
used to make him more
compliant.
"With ammonia in his nose
and hands over his mouth . .
. he can't breathe, he can't
get oxygen," Baden said.
"When he leaves on that
stretcher, he's already
mostly brain dead."
Bay County Medical
Examiner Charles Siebert,
who conducted the first
autopsy, discounted the
beating and said Anderson
died from sickle cell trait,
a common blood disorder
among blacks. But Baden
disputed that, saying the
blood cells probably changed
to the sickle shape after he
died.
Siebert, though, defended
his position in a statement
Thursday night.
"My conclusion, based on
more than a decade of
practice, is that the
exertion from exercise
triggered Mr. Anderson's
sickle cell trait which
caused disseminated
intravascular coagulation,
resulting in hemorrhaging,"
Siebert wrote.
"Complications of sickle
cell trait is the cause of
death. Because exertion from
exercise is a natural
activity, I concluded the
manner of death to be
natural."
Officially, the cause of
death is still unknown.
Hillsborough County Medical
Examiner Vernard Adams ruled
out sickle cell trait and
other natural causes this
week but has not yet settled
on an alternative.
Baden's comments came in
a hearing of the House
Criminal Justice
Appropriations Committee,
which is trying to decide
whether to continue funding
the state's four boot camps.
To counter weeks of
negative attention, boot
camp advocates appeared
before the panel Friday.
"I gotta tell you, I love
this job. And I care about
the kids we work with," said
Sgt. Bobby Bowden, who runs
the Manatee County camp.
Leo Suarez, 20, warmly
described going to the Polk
County boot camp two weeks
ago to break the news of his
marriage.
"They're like my family,"
Suarez said of the drill
instructors he met during a
6-month stay at the Polk
County facility in 2003
following drug charges. He
has not been arrested since,
records show.
Also speaking before the
committee were teachers at
the facilities and a mother
who said the camp changed
her son's life.
The comments came as the
sheriffs who run the state's
four remaining boot camps
began talking about how to
improve their operations and
ongoing tweaking of rules by
the state Juvenile Justice
Department. But Martin
County Sheriff Bob Crowder
delivered a stern reminder
that it will be wasted
effort if the state doesn't
fully fund the programs.
"The death of Martin Lee
Anderson has hit the
juvenile justice system in
the state of Florida like a
thunderclap. It's drawn our
attention," he said. But
"there's been a lot of lip
service and support and
encouragement but it has not
been reflected in the
state's budget document."
Chris Caballero, second
in command at the Juvenile
Justice Department, pointed
Friday to Gov. Jeb Bush's
revised budget putting
$1.5-million more into boot
camps. Money from the Bay
County camp, which closed
after Anderson's death, can
be spread to those that
remain, he noted.
Also Friday, State
Democratic chairwoman Karen
Thurman called for
Hillsborough State Attorney
Mark Ober to be taken off
the investigation, citing
his involvement in the case
of Jennifer Porter, the
white teacher involved in a
hit-and-run accident that
left two black children dead
in Tampa.
"This goes beyond bad
politics. It's bad policy to
appoint an investigator
involved in one
controversial, racially
charged case to investigate
another so soon afterwards,"
Thurman said in a statement.
But the Anderson family
attorney, Ben Crump, has
expressed confidence in Ober. |